Last year was my first time to Mackinac Island and I stayed at the Chippewa. I loved it! The hotel was clean, updated, comfortable beds, and I loved the location. The whirlpool was a lot of fun and held a lot of people. The food is great at the Pink Pony. They have the best chicken salad sandwich! I had such a great time I even came back in October. There was far less people and still had a great time!